Pick the right tool, fast
← All comparisons
Gaming Subscriptions · Tool Face-Off

Xbox Game Pass Ultimate vs PlayStation Plus Extra

Quick answer

Both services offer excellent game libraries, but Xbox Game Pass Ultimate edges ahead with day-one first-party titles and cloud streaming — PlayStation Plus Extra punches back with a deeper classic catalog and Sony exclusives at a lower entry price.

Our pick
Xbox Game Pass Ultimate
Day-one blockbusters, cloud gaming, and Xbox Live Gold in one bundle
4.7★
VS
PlayStation Plus Extra
PlayStation's mid-tier vault packed with Sony exclusives and third-party hits
3.6★
Monthly Price
$19.99/mo
$14.99/mo
Annual Price
~$179.99/yr
~$134.99/yr
Game Library Size
~500+ titles
~400+ titles
Day-One First-Party Releases
Yes — all Xbox studios titles
No — PlayStation exclusives added later
Cloud Streaming
Yes — Xbox, PC, mobile, browser
Limited — PS4/PS5 only via PS Remote Play or PS Now legacy
Online Multiplayer Included
Yes (Gold included)
Yes (PS Plus included)
Classic/Retro Catalog
Limited selection
PS1, PS2, PSP, PS3 classics (Extra/Premium)
PC Gaming Access
Yes — Xbox PC Game Pass included
No PC access
EA Play Included
Yes
No
Free Monthly Games
Yes (rotating selection)
Yes (rotating selection)
Platforms Supported
Xbox, PC, mobile, tablet, browser
PS4, PS5 only
Offline Play
Yes
Yes

Xbox Game Pass Ultimate

Ease of Use★★★★½
Cloud Gaming★★★★★
Value for Money★★★★½
Day-One Releases★★★★★
Multiplayer Access★★★★★
Game Library Quality★★★★½
Platform Flexibility★★★★½

PlayStation Plus Extra

Ease of Use★★★★½
Cloud Gaming★★★☆☆
Value for Money★★★★☆
Day-One Releases★★☆☆☆
Multiplayer Access★★★★½
Game Library Quality★★★★½
Platform Flexibility★★½☆☆

Worth knowing

You can stream Xbox games on a Amazon Fire Stick — meaning you could theoretically play Halo in a hotel bathroom on a $30 stick. Sony has no equivalent. 🚿🎮

If you want

You want the best bang-for-buck with day-one AAA releases

Game Pass Ultimate delivers every Xbox studio title on launch day, plus EA Play and cloud gaming — unmatched day-one value.

→ Pick Xbox Game Pass Ultimate
If you want

You're a PS5 owner on a budget who loves Sony exclusives

PlayStation Plus Extra costs $5/mo less and has a deep Sony exclusive back-catalog, even if day-one titles aren't included.

→ Pick PlayStation Plus Extra
If you want

You want to game without owning a console or high-end PC

Xbox cloud streaming runs on phones, tablets, browsers, and smart TVs — PlayStation has no comparable flexible streaming option.

→ Pick Xbox Game Pass Ultimate
If you want

You're a retro gaming fan craving PS1/PS2 nostalgia

PlayStation's classic game vault at Extra/Premium tier is the only place to officially stream or download those beloved retro PlayStation titles.

→ Pick PlayStation Plus Extra
Xbox Game Pass UltimateVSNintendo Switch Online Expansion Pack
Gaming Subscriptions
PlayStation Plus ExtraVSPlayStation Plus Premium
Gaming Subscriptions
PlayStation PlusVSXbox Game Pass Ultimate
Gaming Subscriptions
Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you sign up through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.