Pick the right tool, fast
← All comparisons
Gaming Subscriptions · Tool Face-Off

PlayStation Plus vs Xbox Game Pass Ultimate

Quick answer

Xbox Game Pass Ultimate is the better all-around subscription for most gamers—day-one first-party titles alone justify the price. PlayStation Plus is catching up but still plays second fiddle on new releases.

PlayStation Plus
Sony's tiered gaming subscription with classics and online play
3.3★
VS
Our pick
Xbox Game Pass Ultimate
Microsoft's all-in-one pass with day-one first-party hits
4.6★
Monthly Price
$9.99–$17.99/mo (3 tiers)
~$19.99/mo (Ultimate)
Annual Cost (top tier)
~$159.99/yr (PS Plus Premium)
~$239.88/yr
Day-One First-Party Games
Rare; most added months later
Yes — all Xbox studios titles at launch
Active Game Library Size
~800+ games (Premium tier)
~500 games (higher quality curation)
Classic/Retro Catalog
Hundreds of PS1–PS4 classics (Premium)
Limited retro titles
PC Gaming Support
No
Yes — full PC Game Pass included
Cloud Streaming
Yes (Premium tier only)
Yes (all Ultimate members)
Online Multiplayer Included
Yes (Essential tier+)
Yes — included in Ultimate
Free Monthly Games
2–4 games/month
2–4 games/month (Perks + EA Play titles)
EA Play Included
No
Yes — full EA Play membership
Mobile Cloud Gaming
No
Yes — select titles on Android/iOS
Exclusive Ecosystem
PlayStation only
Xbox console + PC + cloud

PlayStation Plus

Pricing★★★★☆
Ease of Use★★★★☆
Game Library★★★½☆
New Releases★★½☆☆
Perks & Extras★★★☆☆
Multiplayer Value★★★½☆
Platform Flexibility★★½☆☆

Xbox Game Pass Ultimate

Pricing★★★½☆
Ease of Use★★★★½
Game Library★★★★½
New Releases★★★★★
Perks & Extras★★★★½
Multiplayer Value★★★★½
Platform Flexibility★★★★★

Worth knowing

Microsoft once said Game Pass members play 30% more genres than non-subscribers — apparently unlimited access cures gaming commitment issues.

If you want

You want the best value on new AAA releases

Every Xbox first-party game drops on day one — you'd pay $70+ per title otherwise.

→ Pick Xbox Game Pass Ultimate
If you want

You're a PlayStation loyalist who mainly wants online play and some free games

PS Plus Essential is cheaper and covers everything a PS5 online player actually needs.

→ Pick PlayStation Plus
If you want

You also game on PC

Game Pass Ultimate covers both Xbox and PC, doubling your platform value instantly.

→ Pick Xbox Game Pass Ultimate
If you want

You love retro gaming and classic PlayStation titles

PS Plus Premium has the deepest official Sony classic catalog from PS1 through PS4.

→ Pick PlayStation Plus
Xbox Game Pass UltimateVSNintendo Switch Online Expansion Pack
Gaming Subscriptions
Xbox Game Pass UltimateVSPlayStation Plus Extra
Gaming Subscriptions
PlayStation Plus ExtraVSPlayStation Plus Premium
Gaming Subscriptions
Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you sign up through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.