Gaming Subscriptions · Tool Face-Off

PlayStation Plus Extra vs PlayStation Plus Premium

Quick answer

Premium adds a game catalog and classics library on top of Extra, but most players won't use enough of it to justify the price bump. Extra is the sweet spot for the majority of PS5 owners.

PlayStation Plus Extra

A fat game catalog without the museum wing

2.9★

Our pick

PlayStation Plus Premium

The full PlayStation buffet, vintage section included

3.8★

Monthly Price (approx.)

~$14.99/mo

~$17.99/mo

Annual Price (approx.)

~$99.99/yr

~$119.99/yr

Monthly Games (PS Plus lineup)

Yes

Game Catalog (400+ PS4/PS5 titles)

Yes (~400+ titles)

Classics Catalog (PS1/PS2/PSP/PS3)

Yes (~340+ titles)

Cloud Game Streaming

Yes (PS3 & select titles)

Game Trials

Yes (timed demos of big games)

Ubisoft+ Classics Access

Yes

Online Multiplayer

Yes

Cloud Save Storage

Yes

Download Classic Games

Yes (PS1/PS2/PSP only)

Price Over Essential

+$40/yr over Essential

+$60/yr over Essential

PlayStation Plus Extra

Pricing★★★★☆

Ease of Use★★★★½

Game Catalog★★★★☆

Cloud Streaming★☆☆☆☆

Exclusive Perks★★★½☆

Classics Library★☆☆☆☆

New Release Speed★★★☆☆

PlayStation Plus Premium

Pricing★★★☆☆

Ease of Use★★★★½

Game Catalog★★★★☆

Cloud Streaming★★★★☆

Exclusive Perks★★★★☆

Classics Library★★★★☆

New Release Speed★★★☆☆

Worth knowing

Premium costs about $20/yr more than Extra — roughly the price of one indie game.
The Classics Catalog includes over 340 retro titles spanning PS1, PS2, PSP, and PS3 eras.
Cloud streaming lets Premium members play PS3 games without a PS3, since those can't be downloaded.
Game Trials in Premium let you test full AAA games before buying — a genuinely underrated perk.
Neither tier includes brand-new first-party titles at launch; expect a 6-12 month wait.

PlayStation Premium lets you stream PS3 games but not download them — Sony apparently trusts you with a PS1 disc from 1995 but not a Blu-ray from 2009.

If you want

You just want a big modern game library at a fair price

Extra's 400+ PS4/PS5 catalog covers 95% of what most players actually want without paying the Premium tax.

→ Pick PlayStation Plus Extra

If you want

You grew up with a PlayStation and want the nostalgia hit

The Classics Catalog alone is a retro goldmine — PS1, PS2, and PSP titles you can download and actually own during your sub.

→ Pick PlayStation Plus Premium

If you want

You want to try big AAA games before dropping $70

Game Trials is a Premium-exclusive perk that can easily save you more than the $20 annual price difference.

→ Pick PlayStation Plus Premium

If you want

You're budget-conscious but still want online play

Extra gives you online multiplayer, monthly games, and a huge catalog — Premium's extras rarely justify the gap for casual players.

→ Pick PlayStation Plus Extra

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you sign up through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.