Fire Pits & Grills · Tool Face-Off

Weber Genesis E-325s vs Traeger Pro 575

Quick answer

Weber Genesis E-325s is the king of quick weeknight grills; Traeger Pro 575 is the patient pitmaster's best friend. Pick Weber for flame-kissed sears, Traeger for low-and-slow wood-smoked bliss.

Weber Genesis E-325s

Three-burner gas powerhouse for the impatient griller

4.1★

Our pick

Traeger Pro 575

Set-it-and-forget-it wood pellet smoker with WiFi brains

4.2★

Price (MSRP)

~$900-1,000

~$800-900

Fuel type

Liquid propane or natural gas

Wood pellets

Primary cooking area

669 sq in

575 sq in

Max temperature

~650°F

~500°F

Preheat time

~10-15 min

~15-20 min

WiFi / App control

Yes (WiFIRE app)

Smoke flavor

Minimal (gas)

Rich wood-smoke taste

Direct flame searing

Yes (full open flame)

No (indirect only)

Side burner

Yes (sear station + side burner)

Pellet hopper capacity

N/A

18 lbs (~6-10 hrs)

Assembly difficulty

Moderate (~2-3 hrs)

Easy (~1-1.5 hrs)

Warranty

10 yr (burners), 5 yr (parts)

3 yr (all parts)

Weber Genesis E-325s

Ease of use★★★★★

Versatility★★★½☆

Build quality★★★★½

Flavor output★★★½☆

Value for money★★★★☆

Cooking performance★★★★½

Temperature control★★★★☆

Traeger Pro 575

Ease of use★★★★☆

Versatility★★★★½

Build quality★★★½☆

Flavor output★★★★★

Value for money★★★½☆

Cooking performance★★★★½

Temperature control★★★★½

Worth knowing

Weber's Genesis line has been around since 1985 — it's basically the Honda Civic of gas grills.
The Traeger Pro 575 can also bake, roast, and braise — your oven is shaking in its boots.
Traeger's WiFIRE app lets you adjust temp from the couch, which is either genius or an enabler of laziness.
Weber's sear station burner concentrates heat for steakhouse-level crust without a cast iron skillet.
Running costs differ wildly: propane tanks cost ~$3-4/lb while hardwood pellets run ~$1-1.50/lb.

Traeger literally invented the pellet grill in the 1980s to help a farmer cook a pig — Weber responded by making sure their gas grills could char a steak faster than the farmer could say 'oink.'

If you want

You want dinner on the table in 30 minutes on a Tuesday

Gas ignites instantly, heats fast, and gives you direct flame control for quick sears and weeknight meals.

→ Pick Weber Genesis E-325s

If you want

You want fall-off-the-bone ribs or brisket with real smoke flavor

Traeger's wood pellets deliver genuine smoke rings and flavor that gas simply cannot replicate.

→ Pick Traeger Pro 575

If you want

You love gadgets and monitoring your cook from the couch

WiFIRE app and precise digital temp control make Traeger the smart-home-compatible choice.

→ Pick Traeger Pro 575

If you want

You're feeding a crowd and need maximum grill real estate

At 669 sq in, Weber edges out the Pro 575's 575 sq in and can hit higher temps for faster batch cooking.

→ Pick Weber Genesis E-325s

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you sign up through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.