Snack Food · Tool Face-Off

Oreo Thins vs Oreo Double Stuf

Quick answer

Both are Oreo royalty, but they serve completely different snacking moods. Thins win for elegance and restraint; Double Stuf wins for unapologetic cream-forward indulgence.

Our pick

Oreo Thins

The cookie that thinks it's fancy

3.6★

Oreo Double Stuf

More of the good stuff, zero apologies

3.6★

Creme filling

Thin layer, minimal

2x standard Oreo creme

Cookie thickness

~40% thinner than original

Standard thickness

Calories per cookie

~35 kcal

~70 kcal

Cookies per standard pack

~40 cookies

~29 cookies

Snap sound when bitten

Loud, satisfying crack

Softer, muted snap

Milk dunking time before soggy

~3 seconds

~6 seconds

Twist-and-lick friendly

Not really, too fragile

Absolutely yes

Available flavors

Fewer (4-6 variants)

More (6-10+ variants)

Retail price (standard pack)

~$4-5

Cream cheese frosting vibes

Subtle, balanced

Full-on dessert energy

Stackability

Stacks like a dream

Wobbly due to thick filling

Office snack respectability

High — looks refined

Low — people WILL judge you

Oreo Thins

Dunkability★★★☆☆

Guilt Level★★★½☆

Snackability★★★★☆

Crunch Factor★★★★½

Flavor Balance★★★★½

Value for Money★★★½☆

Creme-to-Cookie Ratio★★☆☆☆

Oreo Double Stuf

Dunkability★★★★☆

Guilt Level★★☆☆☆

Snackability★★★★½

Crunch Factor★★★☆☆

Flavor Balance★★★½☆

Value for Money★★★½☆

Creme-to-Cookie Ratio★★★★★

Worth knowing

Oreo Thins launched in 2015 and became one of the brand's fastest-selling new products ever.
Double Stuf has been around since 1974 — it's older than most of its fans.
Despite the name, studies suggest Double Stuf contains roughly 1.86x the filling, not exactly 2x.
Oreo Thins have about half the calories per cookie, but nobody eats just one.
Double Stuf is the cookie of choice for the twist-lick-dunk ritual, thanks to that generous creme slab.

A math teacher famously assigned students to measure whether Double Stuf was actually double — and Nabisco got so roasted by the results they've never officially confirmed the ratio since.

If you want

You want a lighter snack that won't destroy your afternoon

Fewer calories per cookie and a crunchier bite make Thins feel like a grown-up compromise.

→ Pick Oreo Thins

If you want

You live for the creme and the ritual

Double Stuf is built for twisting, licking, and dunking — it's the full Oreo experience cranked to 11.

→ Pick Oreo Double Stuf

If you want

You're pairing cookies with coffee or tea

Thins' balanced flavor doesn't overpower a hot drink; they're practically a biscotti.

→ Pick Oreo Thins

If you want

You're sharing with kids or a party crowd

Double Stuf wins on novelty, fun factor, and sheer crowd-pleasing creme volume.

→ Pick Oreo Double Stuf

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you sign up through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.