Quick answerMLB.TV is the undisputed king for die-hard baseball fans wanting every out-of-market game, while Peacock Premium is a better all-around streamer that happens to carry some MLB content plus tons of other sports and entertainment.
Price
~$24.99/mo or ~$149.99/season
$7.99/mo (Premium) or $13.99/mo (Premium Plus, no ads)
Live MLB Games
All out-of-market games (~2,400+/season)
Select exclusive Sunday games ('Sunday Leadoff')
Local/In-Market Blackouts
Yes — local team games blacked out
No blackout issues for its select games
Simultaneous Streams
Up to 4 devices
3 streams simultaneously
Condensed/Archive Games
Yes — full archives, condensed games, highlights
No deep archive; limited replays
Postseason/Playoffs
No — playoff rights not included
Some playoff games (NBC/Peacock-broadcast only)
Non-Sports Content
None — baseball only
NBC shows, movies, Premier League, Olympics, WWE
Home Run Derby / All-Star
Not included (national broadcast events excluded)
Yes, when broadcast on Peacock/NBC
Audio Options
Home/away radio broadcasts included
Standard broadcast audio only
Free Trial
Rare/no consistent free trial
Occasional free trials available
Ad-Free Option
Yes (no ads during game action)
Yes — Premium Plus tier ($13.99/mo)
VPN Workaround for Blackouts
Technically possible but against ToS
N/A — no blackout system to circumvent
MLB.TV
Ease of Use★★★½☆
MLB Content Depth★★★★★
Streaming Quality★★★★☆
Device Compatibility★★★★☆
Non-Baseball Content★☆☆☆☆
Value for Baseball Fans★★★★½
Peacock Premium
Ease of Use★★★★½
MLB Content Depth★★☆☆☆
Streaming Quality★★★★☆
Device Compatibility★★★★½
Non-Baseball Content★★★★½
Value for Baseball Fans★★½☆☆
If you wantYou want to follow every game of a team that's not local to you
MLB.TV is the only service with the full out-of-market game catalog — nothing else comes close for obsessive fans.
→ Pick MLB.TV If you wantYou want a low-cost streamer with some live MLB plus other sports and entertainment
Peacock is cheaper, covers Premier League and NBC content, and its MLB Sunday games are a nice bonus without a premium price.
→ Pick Peacock Premium If you wantYou live in the same city as your favorite team and want to watch them live
MLB.TV will black out every single local game, making it nearly useless for home-market fans — Peacock at least won't tease you.
→ Pick Peacock Premium If you wantYou're a stats-obsessed fan who loves condensed games and radio broadcasts
MLB.TV's archive depth, home/away audio feeds, and condensed game format are unmatched for the true baseball nerd.
→ Pick MLB.TV Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you sign up through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.