Grocery Delivery Subscriptions · Tool Face-Off

Instacart+ vs Walmart+ Delivery

Quick answer

Walmart+ edges out Instacart+ for most shoppers thanks to lower membership cost and broader perks, but Instacart+ wins if you shop at multiple premium grocers or live outside Walmart's delivery range.

Instacart+

Your personal shopper, for basically every store in town

3.9★

Our pick

Walmart+ Delivery

Walmart prices, delivered — plus a surprising pile of extras

4.2★

Monthly price

$9.99/mo

$12.95/mo

Annual price

$99/yr

$98/yr

Free delivery threshold

$35+ orders

Number of stores available

1,400+ retailers nationwide

Walmart stores only (4,700+ locations)

Service fees waived

Yes (on eligible orders)

Yes (delivery fee waived)

Fuel savings

10¢/gal off at Exxon/Mobil & Walmart stations

Streaming bonus

Paramount+ Essential included (~$7.99/mo value)

Pickup discount

No extra discount

Members-only item discounts in-store & online

Same-day delivery

Yes, often within 1-2 hrs

Yes, Express delivery option (+fee)

Tipping

Shoppers expect tips (adds ~10-20% to order)

No tipping (Walmart employees deliver)

Alcohol delivery

Yes, where legal

Free trial

14 days

30 days

Instacart+

Ease of Use★★★★½

Delivery Speed★★★★½

Perks & Extras★★★☆☆

Pricing & Fees★★★☆☆

Store Selection★★★★★

Membership Value★★★½☆

Walmart+ Delivery

Ease of Use★★★★½

Delivery Speed★★★★☆

Perks & Extras★★★★★

Pricing & Fees★★★★½

Store Selection★★½☆☆

Membership Value★★★★½

Worth knowing

Instacart+ covers Aldi, Costco, Kroger, Petco, and hundreds more — all in one app.
Walmart+ members get Paramount+ Essential streaming included, which nearly covers half the annual fee alone.
Instacart shoppers are gig workers, so tipping is socially expected and can easily add $5-10+ per order.
Walmart+ offers scan-and-go in-store shopping via app — skip the checkout line entirely.
Instacart charges per-item markups at many retailers on top of membership and tip costs.

Walmart+ includes a Paramount+ subscription — meaning you're technically paying for grocery delivery and accidentally getting a TV streaming service. Your Netflix is shaking.

If you want

You shop at multiple grocery chains (Kroger, Costco, Aldi, etc.)

Instacart+ is the only way to get free delivery across 1,400+ retailers in one membership.

→ Pick Instacart+

If you want

You primarily shop at Walmart and want the best overall value

No tips, fuel savings, Paramount+ streaming, and in-store perks make Walmart+ a stacked deal for loyal Walmart shoppers.

→ Pick Walmart+ Delivery

If you want

You hate tipping and want predictable delivery costs

Walmart uses its own employees, so there's zero tipping culture — your $35 order actually costs $35.

→ Pick Walmart+ Delivery

If you want

You need ultra-fast delivery from premium or local grocery stores

Instacart's shopper network can often deliver in under 2 hours from stores Walmart simply doesn't carry.

→ Pick Instacart+

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you sign up through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.