Investing · Tool Face-Off

Berkshire Hathaway Stock vs S&P 500 Index Fund

Quick answer

For most investors, an S&P 500 index fund wins on cost, diversification, and simplicity. Berkshire Hathaway is a compelling single-stock alternative with legendary management — but it's still a single stock.

Berkshire Hathaway Stock

Warren Buffett's conglomerate masquerading as a stock

3.2★

Our pick

S&P 500 Index Fund

500 companies for the price of one ticker

4.5★

Expense Ratio

0% (no fund fee, but broker commissions apply)

0.03%–0.20% (e.g., VOO, SPY, FSKAX)

Single Share Price (Class A)

~$600,000+ (BRK.A) / ~$400 (BRK.B)

$50–$500 depending on fund/ETF

Number of Holdings

~65 stocks + wholly owned subsidiaries

~500 large-cap U.S. companies

Dividend Paid

None (Buffett famously hates dividends)

~1.3%–1.6% annual yield

10-Year Annualized Return (approx.)

~13–15% (BRK.B, varies by period)

~12–13% (S&P 500 total return)

Fractional Shares

BRK.B yes; BRK.A rarely

Yes, widely available

Tax Efficiency

High — no fund distributions, no turnover costs

Very high for ETF versions (e.g., VOO); mutual funds vary

Management Risk

Key-person risk: Buffett is 93, Munger passed in 2023

Passive — no manager to worry about

Sector Concentration

Heavy financials, insurance, energy, consumer

Broad across all 11 GICS sectors

Minimum Investment

~$400 (BRK.B) or fractional

$1 with fractional shares at most brokers

Regulatory Filings

Annual report + 13F quarterly filings

Daily holdings disclosure (ETF) or semi-annual (mutual fund)

Volatility (Beta approx.)

~0.85 — historically less volatile than market

1.0 by definition (it IS the benchmark)

Berkshire Hathaway Stock

Risk Profile★★★☆☆

Transparency★★★½☆

Ease of Entry★★★☆☆

Diversification★★★½☆

Value for Price★★★★☆

Dividend / Income★☆☆☆☆

Long-term Performance★★★★½

S&P 500 Index Fund

Risk Profile★★★★☆

Transparency★★★★★

Ease of Entry★★★★★

Diversification★★★★★

Value for Price★★★★★

Dividend / Income★★★½☆

Long-term Performance★★★★☆

Worth knowing

Berkshire Hathaway beat the S&P 500 over Buffett's full tenure (1965–2023) by roughly 2x cumulative, but has lagged the index in several recent 10-year windows.
S&P 500 index funds collectively hold over $7 trillion in assets, making them the most popular investment vehicle on Earth.
BRK.A shares have never been split and remain the highest-priced stock on the NYSE.
Over 90% of actively managed funds underperform the S&P 500 over 15 years — Berkshire is a rare exception.
Berkshire holds over $150 billion in cash equivalents, which drags returns in bull markets but cushions crashes.

Warren Buffett himself has instructed the trustee of his estate to put 90% of his wife's inheritance into an S&P 500 index fund — so even Buffett is endorsing the competition.

If you want

You want maximum diversification at minimum cost

500 companies, fees near zero, and zero key-person risk make it the default smart choice.

→ Pick S&P 500 Index Fund

If you want

You want market exposure with a slightly defensive tilt and you trust Buffett's successors

Berkshire's lower beta, hidden asset value, and zero dividend drag can outperform in volatile markets.

→ Pick Berkshire Hathaway Stock

If you want

You're a beginner with under $1,000 to invest

Fractional shares, instant diversification, and automatic rebalancing remove all the hard decisions.

→ Pick S&P 500 Index Fund

If you want

You want to avoid ever paying fund fees or fund capital-gains distributions

Owning BRK.B is effectively a free, actively managed fund with zero expense ratio or distribution events.

→ Pick Berkshire Hathaway Stock

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you sign up through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.