Interior Paint · Tool Face-Off

Behr Premium Plus vs Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint

Quick answer

SuperPaint edges out Behr Premium Plus on coverage and durability, but Behr fights back hard on price. For most DIYers, Behr is the wallet-friendly workhorse; pros and perfectionists will reach for SuperPaint.

Behr Premium Plus

The Home Depot house brand that punches above its price tag

3.9★

Our pick

Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint

The contractor's go-to that moonlights as a premium DIY paint

4.1★

Price per gallon (retail)

~$30–36

~$55–72 (frequent 30–40% sales)

Coverage per gallon

~350–400 sq ft

~400 sq ft

Coats typically needed

2 coats standard

Often 1–2 coats

Primer included

Yes (paint + primer)

VOC level

Low VOC (~50 g/L)

Low VOC (~38 g/L)

Finish options

Flat, Eggshell, Satin, Semi-Gloss, Gloss

Flat, Eg-Shel, Satin, Semi-Gloss, Gloss

Color palette size

~1,000+ colors

1,700+ colors (ColorSnap system)

Scrubability / washability

Good (passes ASTM D2486)

Excellent (higher scrub cycle rating)

Mildew resistance

Yes (built-in)

Yes (built-in, stronger additive)

Where to buy

Home Depot only

Sherwin-Williams stores only

Dry time (recoat)

~4 hours

Consumer Reviews (avg)

~4.3/5 on Home Depot

~4.5/5 on SW site

Behr Premium Plus

Durability★★★½☆

Availability★★★★☆

Low VOC / Odor★★★½☆

Color Selection★★★★☆

Coverage & Hide★★★½☆

Value for Money★★★★½

Ease of Application★★★★☆

Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint

Durability★★★★½

Availability★★★½☆

Low VOC / Odor★★★★☆

Color Selection★★★★★

Coverage & Hide★★★★½

Value for Money★★★☆☆

Ease of Application★★★★½

Worth knowing

Behr Premium Plus regularly tops budget paint rankings — you're getting solid performance for roughly half the price of SuperPaint.
SuperPaint's higher pigment load means fewer gallons used on large projects, which partially offsets its higher sticker price.
Sherwin-Williams runs 30–40% off sales multiple times per year, making SuperPaint's effective price much more competitive.
Behr is exclusively sold at Home Depot, while SuperPaint requires a trip to a Sherwin-Williams store — neither is universally convenient.
Independent lab tests (Consumer Reports, painting YouTubers) consistently rank SuperPaint 1–2 tiers above Behr Premium Plus in hide and durability.

Behr's parent company is Masco — the same conglomerate that owns Delta Faucets. Yes, the people sealing your pipes are also painting your walls.

If you want

You want the best bang-for-buck for a rental or budget reno

Behr Premium Plus delivers respectable results at ~half the cost, and it's always in stock at every Home Depot.

→ Pick Behr Premium Plus

If you want

You want a flawless, long-lasting finish on your forever home

SuperPaint's superior hide, washability, and color depth mean fewer touch-ups and a result you'll still love in 10 years.

→ Pick Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint

If you want

You're a contractor painting multiple rooms fast

Better single-coat coverage and lower VOCs make SuperPaint the professional's productivity pick.

→ Pick Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint

If you want

You caught a Sherwin-Williams 40% off sale

At sale price (~$33–43/gal), SuperPaint beats Behr Premium Plus on virtually every metric at comparable cost.

→ Pick Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint

Behr MarqueeVSBenjamin Moore Regal Select

Interior Paint

Sherwin-Williams EmeraldVSBehr Marquee

Interior Paint

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you sign up through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Behr Premium Plus vs Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint

Behr Premium Plus

Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint

Worth knowing

More face-offs like this